Best Apples For Apple Butter

Best Apples For Apple Butter

As summer transitions into fall and temperatures start to drop, apple season begins! For many people, this means it’s time to stock up on apples as we prepare for a number of desserts. One delicious treat that you can make is homemade apple butter. Apple butter has long been a beloved staple of American kitchens, providing sweet and delicious flavor to many dishes. Whether you’re new to making apple butter or have been doing it for years, choosing the best apples is key to achieving the ideal results. With so many varieties of apples on the market, it can be tricky to choose which ones are right for this time-honored recipe. 

In this post, we’ll take a look at the types of apples that work best in apple butter so that buyers can make an informed decision when selecting their ingredients. Read on to learn more about the best types of apples you should use when cooking up your own batch.
Best Apples For Apple Butter

What are apples?

Apples are a type of fruit that grows on trees. They come in a variety of colors and sizes, ranging from small tart green apples to large sweet red apples. Apples have a firm texture and sweet taste; they can be eaten raw, used in recipes, or juiced for their juice. Apples are rich in vitamins A, C, E and B-complex as well as minerals such as potassium, phosphorus and magnesium. Eating an apple a day is said to help keep the doctor away due to its high fiber content which helps promote digestive health. They’re also packed with antioxidants like polyphenols which may reduce the risk of certain cancers and heart disease. For those looking for an easy snack choice that is high in nutrition, apples are a great option. Enjoy them as is or try baking an apple crisp for a delicious treat! 

What is apple butter?

Apple butter is a spread made from cooked apples, sugar, and spices. It is often used as an alternative to jam or jelly. The consistency of apple butter tends to be thicker and smoother than traditional jams or jellies; it is usually darker in color due to the long cooking process necessary for making it. Apple butter has a sweet-tart flavor that pairs wonderfully with toast, muffins, pancakes and waffles. It can also be added to oatmeal or yogurt for extra flavor. Apple butter is a great way to enjoy the delicious taste of apples without all the hassle of cutting them up! Whether you’re looking for a simple snack or something special to add to your breakfast table, apple butter is sure to please.

History of apple butter

Apple butter has a long history, going all the way back to colonial America. It was a popular way of preserving apples for future use; it was also used as a sweetener in recipes that didn’t call for much sugar. American settlers would cook apples in large kettles over an open fire, stirring the mixture constantly until it turned into a thick spread. Apple butter is still made this traditional way today, although modern-day cooks often speed up the process by using electric slow cookers or pressure cookers. Whether you’re making your own apple butter at home or buying it from a store, you can enjoy its delicious flavor any time of year!  From its beginnings as a colonial staple to modern-day use, apple butter has been enjoyed by many for centuries. Its unique flavor will continue to be treasured for years to come!

What are some of the benefits of apple butter?

Apple butter contains a variety of vitamins and minerals including vitamin C, fiber, potassium and magnesium. It is also low in fat, calories and cholesterol making it an ideal spread for those looking to keep their diets healthy. Apples are naturally high in antioxidants, which can reduce the risk of developing certain cancers and heart disease. The spices added to apple butter such as cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg and clove can provide even more antioxidant benefits! Apple butter is also a great source of natural energy thanks to its simple sugars and carbohydrates; this makes it perfect for fueling your day or providing an afternoon pick-me-up when you’re feeling sluggish. All in all, apple butter is a delicious way to enjoy the flavor of apples while reaping the health benefits of this wonderful fruit. 

Which apples make the best apple butter?

Apples are available in over 100 different types in the United States. Apple cultivars are used for a variety of purposes, including pies, sauce, and apple butter. Certain apples lend themselves better to apple butter over others.

It is ideal to use a tender apple while making apple butter. Soft apples are preferable since they cook quickly, resulting in softer apple butter. You may make apple butter from the same sorts of apples or from a range of apples.

1. Fuji apples: 

Fuji apples were first produced in Japan in the early 1900s prior to their journey to the United States in the 1980s. Fuji apples give a sweet flavor and creamy texture when cooked. These apples are known for their soft and juicy flesh, making them great for apple butter.

2. Honeycrisp apples: 

Honeycrisp apples bring an ample amount of sweetness to any recipe, including apple butter. The firmness of these distinctively crispy apples makes it possible to create smooth looking apple butter.

3. Gala Apples: 

Gala apples have a relatively thin skin that produces a unique pinkish-orange color when cooked. This type of apple is popular in many recipes, including apple butter as they are both tart and sweet in flavor.

4. Granny Smith Apples: 

Granny Smiths have a bright green skin and are known for their tart flavor. These apples are some of the best to use in recipes, including apple butter. The tartness balances out the sweetness from other ingredients, making it ideal for a spreadable apple butter.

5. Braeburn apples:

The Braeburn apple was first grown in New Zealand in the 1950s. It is popular because of its sweet taste as well as its crunchy and moist texture. It is a common apple that is obtainable from October to July and is utilized in a variety of cuisines. It’s an excellent apple to use for apple butter because of the balance between tart and sweet notes.

6. Golden delicious apples:

These apples have a light yellow-green skin and are known for their sweet taste. It is an excellent apple to use in recipes due to its mild sweetness and thick flesh, which helps make a smooth apple butter.

7. Jonathan apples:

The Jonathan apple originated in the United States and has a deep red color when ripe. It has a tart flavor that gives it the perfect balance of sweet and sour. The texture of this apple makes it ideal for creating creamy textures in your apple butter recipe.

8. Cortland apples:

The Cortland apple has a white flesh that makes it one of the best apples to use for apple butter. Its sweet flavor and firm texture make it a great choice for achieving a smooth apple spread with plenty of flavor.

Overall, there are many varieties of apples you can use for making apple butter. While some apples may work better than others, all of them will still produce delicious results! The most important thing is to choose ripe fruit and pair them with other ingredients, such as sugar, spices, and butter to create the perfect combination. Enjoy experimenting with different types of apples and discovering your favorite flavors in the process.

How to make apple butter – a step by step instruction? 

Making apple butter is a simple process that doesn’t require much work. All you need are some apples, spices, and sugar to get started! Here’s how to make your own apple butter.

  1. Gather the ingredients: You will need 5-6 pounds of apples (any tart variety), 1 cup of white sugar, 2 tablespoons of cinnamon, and 1/4 teaspoon of ground cloves.
  2. Peel and core the apples: Peel and core the apples in order to remove any tough skin or seeds from the flesh. This can be done manually or with an apple peeler/corer tool available at most kitchen stores.
  3. Simmer the apples: Place the cored apples into a large pot and add enough water to cover them halfway. Bring the mixture to a boil, reduce the heat, and simmer for 15-20 minutes or until the apples are soft.
  4. Mash the apples: Use a potato masher or immersion blender to mash the softened apples into a smooth texture. This can also be done in batches if you prefer.
  5. Sweeten and spice it up: Add the sugar, cinnamon, and ground cloves to the mashed apples. Stir well so that all of the ingredients are fully combined.
  6. Cook it down: Continue cooking over medium heat for about an hour, stirring occasionally, until it has reached a thick spreadable consistency (like peanut butter). You may need to adjust the cooking time based on the type of apples you used and how low your heat is set.
  7. Can it: Once your apple butter has reached the desired consistency, you can either store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two weeks or can it for longer-term storage. To can your apple butter, fill clean jars with the mixture and process them using a boiling water bath technique for 10 minutes. Allow the jars to cool completely before storing them away for future use. And there you have it!

Is it possible to make apple butter with Ginger Gold apples?

Ginger Gold apples are a sweet and juicy variety that work well for apple butter. They contain tart, spicy notes that help to enhance the flavor of the spread and their firm texture helps create a smooth consistency. As with any other apples, it’s best to use ripe Ginger Gold apples for your apple butter recipe in order to get the most flavor out of them. When cooked down, these apples tend to become softer and sweeter, which makes them an ideal choice for making delicious apple butter.

Can winesap apples be used to make apple butter?

Yes, Winesap apples can be used to make apple butter. This variety of apple has a tart taste that pairs well with the sweet flavor of sugar and spices. Its firm texture also helps create a smooth spreadable consistency when cooked down. However, it’s important to note that Winesap apples tend to become quite soft when cooked, so you may need to cook them for a shorter time than other varieties in order to avoid over-mashing them. For the best results, use ripe Winesap apples and adjust your cooking time accordingly

How long does it take for apple butter to thicken?

The amount of time it takes for apple butter to thicken depends on the type of apples used, as well as the cooking temperature. Generally speaking, it should take around an hour to reach a spreadable consistency when cooked over medium heat. However, if you are using a variety of apple that is softer and more prone to mashing (such as Winesap apples), then you may need to adjust your cooking time accordingly. Begin checking at 45 minutes and continue cooking until you have reached your desired consistency.

Are applesauce and apple butter the same?

No, applesauce and apple butter are not the same. Applesauce is made by simply mashing or blending cooked apples with minimal spices or sugar added, while apple butter is cooked down for a much longer period of time with sugar and spices added to it. Apple sauce tends to be thinner in texture and have more tart flavor than apple butter, which is thicker in texture and has a richer, sweeter flavor. Additionally, apple butter can be canned for long-term storage, while applesauce should be stored in the fridge or freezer as it does not keep as well in cans.

How do you know when apple butter is done?

Apple butter is done when it has reached a thick spreadable consistency that is similar to peanut butter. To check if your apple butter has reached the right consistency, spoon some onto the back of a cold plate and tilt it slightly. If the spread holds its shape and doesn’t move, then it is done. If it is still runny and does not hold its shape, then continue cooking until it is thick enough. Additionally, you can also test the flavor of your apple butter to determine if it needs more spices or sugar. Once you have reached the desired consistency, can your apple butter for long-term storage or store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two weeks.

Why does my apple butter have a bitter taste?

Apple butter can taste bitter if the wrong type of apples were used, or if it wasn’t cooked long enough. Bitter flavors are often associated with unripe or tart apples, so using a sweeter variety such as Ginger Gold will help to avoid this issue. Additionally, make sure that you cook your apple butter for long enough to reach the right consistency. If it is still runny after an hour of cooking then continue cooking until you reach your desired thickness. If needed, adjust the amount of sugar and spices in order to reduce any bitter undertones.

What are some other uses of apple butter?

Apple butter can be used in a variety of ways, such as a condiment on toast and sandwiches, as an addition to oatmeal or yogurt, or even as a topping for ice cream. Additionally, it can be added to recipes such as muffins, pancakes and cakes for extra flavor. Apple butter also makes a great glaze for meats such as pork chops or chicken breasts. Finally, it can also be used in savory dishes such as soups and stews to add depth of flavor. The uses are endless when it comes to apple butter! All you need is your imagination and creativity to come up with your own unique recipes. 


Apple butter is one of the most popular ways to enjoy the delicious and nutritious seasonal fruit. Although some claim there is only one perfect baking apple, the truth is that many different varieties can be used to make delicious apple butter. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and experimentation – some prefer a tart Granny Smith or a sweet Honeycrisp; others are partial to Braeburns or Fujis. By understanding the nuances between varieties, apple enthusiasts can have fun with their kitchen experiments and develop custom flavors based on sweetness, texture, and texture. With just a few ingredients required and relatively little effort, apple butter can easily become a favorite staple in any kitchen.


Apple butter – Wikipedia

Apple Butter

Grading Manual for Apple Butter

How to Make an Apple Pie – wikiHow

Leave a Reply